Not since John F Kennedy’s presidency within the early Sixties has a Catholic politician been elected to the USA’s highest workplace.
By all accounts, President Joe Biden’s religion is not phony, compelled, or ammunition for a photo opportunity.
(And in contrast to JFK, who ruled throughout an period of anti-Catholic sentiment, Mr Biden hasn’t made any makes an attempt to distance himself from the Vatican.)
However his liberal views on two polarising subjects — abortion and gender rights — nonetheless have some non secular constituents, and leaders, up in arms.
In keeping with Massimo Faggioli, an creator and non secular research professor at Villanova College in Mr Biden’s residence state of Pennsylvania, the forty sixth president is an “old-style Catholic”.
“He has all the time stated, ‘My Catholic religion has stored me alive,'” says Dr Faggioli.
Mr Biden has skilled extra loss than the typical politician.
In 1972, his first spouse Neilia and their one-year-old daughter Naomi died in a automobile crash. The couple’s sons, Beau and Hunter, survived the accident.
In 2015, one other tragedy struck the household. Mr Biden’s youthful son Beau, a Delaware-based politician and lawyer, handed away from mind most cancers.
Mr Biden says the lack of his son — who inspired him to run for workplace — was a motivating consider his presidential bid.
Christianity at a time of disaster
For creator and ethical and political theology professor Luke Bretherton, Catholicism supplied Mr Biden with the “language of lament”, and a approach to course of grief by means of ritual.
The Duke College tutorial factors out that earlier leaders — who’ve proven “tone deafness to the human situation” — Mr Biden is uniquely positioned to take care of the disaster unfolding in America.
“[Mr Biden can] very naturally reply to one thing like COVID-19 and 400,000 deaths,” Professor Bretherton says.
His actions are in stark distinction to these of presidential predecessor Donald Trump, who downplayed the virus on each a nationwide stage and personally, after he examined constructive to COVID-19.
From Professor Bretherton’s perspective, Mr Trump refused to acknowledge the rising demise toll, and his accountability, as a result of such an act would have been akin to admitting to failure.
“It will have been an indication of his lack of virility, it could have dented his masculinity,” he says.
However Professor Bretherton does not consider ego was the one issue, and hyperlinks Mr Trump’s actions to spiritual perception.
“I’d say he does have a theology, it is a sort of prosperity theology — you see that in who he drew round him, folks like [US televangelist] Paula White,” he says.
“We have seen that scaled up underneath Trump. We have all needed to reside in some bizarre denial about what the f*** is going on to us.”
In October final yr, Pew Analysis Centre discovered that white Evangelicals, Protestants and even Catholics viewed Mr Trump as their preferred candidate.
And regardless that an brazenly non secular Catholic — Joe Biden — was working for presidency, the US Catholic bishops’ conference aligned itself with Mr Trump earlier than, throughout, and even after the election.
Dr Faggioli factors out that no matter whether or not Mr Trump is a real believer, the previous president grew to become an emblem for a lot of Christian Individuals — notably these with conservative views round abortion and LGBTQIA+ rights.
Dr Faggioli says the pro-life/pro-choice debate sits on the coronary heart of the rift between the bishops’ convention and the brand new president.
Whereas Mr Biden opposed the Roe v Wade ruling early on in his political profession, in current many years he has taken a liberal stance in help of abortion.
Dr Faggioli says regardless that Mr Biden wears points like abortion and gender rights “frivolously” — that means they are not central to his platform, which focusses extra on inequality and the atmosphere — he sits squarely within the Democrat camp.
For a lot of non secular constituents and leaders, these two ideologies are incompatible.
Final yr, Wisconsin-based Catholic Father James Altman launched a monologue on YouTube, titled You cannot be Catholic & a Democrat. Period., unpacking this stance. It is had greater than 1.2 million views.
The paradox of US Christianity
Provided that Mr Biden’s method, function and ethical code appear mild years away from Mr Trump’s, how can each males belong to the identical perception system?
Professor Bretherton says Christianity has been used to defend and validate diametrically opposed beliefs in America for lots of of years.
He argues that Protestant Christianity — a “white type of faith” — was dominant within the nation’s basis period, however that it additionally, paradoxically, gave start to the African-American church.
In keeping with Professor Bretherton, Christianity has been used to each legitimise and decry slavery, civil rights and segregation.
He says the transition from Mr Trump to Mr Biden could possibly be seen as a handover from Christian nationalism — used to reinscribe white supremacy and racial capitalism — to a type of Catholic, Protestant and African-American Christianity that helps particular person rights, progressive taxation insurance policies and extra built-in education.
“One can perceive it as a sort of seesaw,” Professor Bretherton says.
“There’s this fixed motion that also continues to play out right this moment.”
RN in your inbox
Get extra tales that transcend the information cycle with our weekly publication.